Yhave to go back At the height of Bob Dylan’s cultural relevance, a critic and stalker scoured the songwriter trash to find a musician who would attract as many amateur codebreakers as Taylor Swift. That’s when I started looking for clues about the lyrics. Swift sparked a frenzy by declaring that basically everything around her, including her songs, liner notes, and social media posts, can have hidden meaning embedded in them. There is.like she said of washington post In 2022, she and her fans “immersed themselves in color-coding, numerology, word searches, clever clues, and Easter eggs.”
That treasure-hunting mentality can lead would-be decipherers in directions the singer doesn’t want, like “Gaylor,” who searches for signals that Swift is secretly queer. Now, another subculture is getting in on the act. Some in the Republican Party have invoked evidence of suspicion that Swift is a deep state spy operative and that perhaps — and we’re just asking here — the NFL is involved in it. There is. .
The theory first gained mainstream attention last month when Fox’s Jesse Watters aired a video showing that “the Pentagon’s psychological operations unit turned Taylor Swift into an asset.” The person speaking in the video isn’t actually from the Pentagon, and she was citing Swift as a common example of celebrity influence, but in any case this is all about Swift becoming super popular. Although this happened many years later, Watters still seemed to think he might be able to explain the “why or.” Why did she explode like this? ” He then interviewed a former FBI agent who said that Joe Biden’s presidential campaign wants Swift’s support (which is true) and that she could shift a significant number of votes into Biden’s column. (This is not a track record that popular music support has historically had.) (It was the same in American politics.)
Rumors of a psychological operation took on its most infamous form a few weeks later. Vivek Ramaswamy himself was a presidential candidate until recently. Posted in X“Who will win next month’s Super Bowl? And will there be massive presidential support from artificially culturally supported couples this fall? This is a bit of wild speculation, but… Let’s see how it ages over the next eight months.”
Yes, that was a reference to Swift and her boyfriend, Travis Kelce of the Kansas City Chiefs.I’ve heard many ruminations over the years about both election fraud and a rigged Super Bowl, but this may be the first time I’ve seen someone imply that conspirators could rig the election. by Super Bowl Cheating.
But aside from that new wrinkle, none of this is unprecedented. In fact, as strange as this story of psychological operations may sound, it is just a step away from fairly common ideas about culture. To hear some people say, almost all pop is OP.
Cconspiracy theory There are many different aspects to the music industry. A century ago, to take an even uglier example, Henry Ford’s dearborn independent He claimed that the “Jewish Federation” was suppressing Gentile music and promoting jazz. “Popular music is a Jewish monopoly” the paper declared in 1921. “Jazz is a Jewish creation. The muddy, muddy, sly allusions, the abandoned sensuality of the sliding notes are of Jewish origin.”
You didn’t need to be a Ford-esque bigot to suspect that there was a cabal behind the music you hated. In 1958, Vance Packard is the author of the following books: hidden persuadersIn a best-selling attack on the advertising industry, the U.S. Senate declared, “The public was manipulated to like rock and roll,” and “The rock and roll, hillbilly, and Latin American movements were engineered and manipulated primarily for profit. ” he testified.of [music-licensing group] BMI. When a Michigan senator objected to the fact that many of his constituents liked pure hillbilly music, Packard replied, “I like some parts of it, too, but the quality of music these days has declined.” I think there is,” he replied in agreement.
The psychedelic sixties gave us pamphlets like David A. Nobel’s. Communism, hypnosis, and the Beatles (claimed the Kremlin was using the Fab Four to induce “artificial neuroses” in American children) and Gary Allen’s The music: It’s not just what you hear (It has been speculated that the Beatles’ music was “compiled by behavioral scientists in some ‘think tank'”). Then came the cover-up panic that peaked in the 1980s, with many pastors, teachers, broadcasters, and members of Congress claiming that conspirators were inserting backwards satanic messages into rock records, potentially targeting young people. I became convinced that he was trying to lead listeners to Lucifer.
But the most popular music devil theory may be the suspicion that the industry itself is a vast, vast labyrinth of conspiracies, a suspicion that owes much of its popularity to the fact that there is a lot of truth to it. not. The world of music is certainly full of secret intrigues, but they’re more subtle than grand. Over the years, people have conspired to bribe DJs, extort artists’ royalties, make fun of streaming service statistics, or otherwise…sometimes… manufacture hits and keep all the profits. The sordid business of scooping up. And God knows the industry PR machine can be a fountain of lies. that’s right. Music marketers work behind the scenes to create and sell images, sometimes cutting ethical corners in the process.
These facts feed into the more dubious intuition of imagining the masses as passive recipients of the products of the culture industry, robot-like consumers of all the products that are thrust upon us. When Mr. Packard spoke with these senators, much of his testimony included plausible allegations of backroom dealing practices. But he also declared that if the industry wanted, it could “make us all sing the zinc miner’s song or sing the War of 1812 march.” In this vision, marketers are not just slippery, they are omnipotent. It’s OP all the way.
IIf marketers believe that Now that you’ve uncovered the secret to inducing demand for junk, it won’t be difficult to expand the story’s characters to include the National Security State, the White House, or any other villain of your choice.True, sometimes secret forces do Trying to insert itself into popular culture, as when the Pentagon offers filmmakers access to its personnel and materials in exchange for script approval. When people learn about these actual propaganda drives, the scope of their imagined covert operations expands.
But these puppeteer stories greatly exaggerate the conformity of the audience. viva brother, Cat Like movies and the New Chorus in music, there are countless examples of things that were relentlessly hyped but failed to sell. And it’s hard to imagine the industry being any better at selling non-music products like presidential candidates.
Even the most advanced Department of Defense programs cannot reliably guide what cultural products we buy or what messages we take away from them. If Taylor Swift was really an operator, I doubt she would be a very effective operator. It’s true that registrations to her website spiked when she shared a link to her Vote.org on National Voter Registration Day last year, but the size of that spike is often exaggerated. . (No, she didn’t single-handedly get her 35,000-plus people to register.) But getting people to fill out a short form online, getting them to vote, much less registering themselves There is a difference in getting people to vote the way they do.
A more realistic look at Swift’s likely impact was published late last month. newsweek According to the survey, 18 percent of voters say they are more likely to vote for a candidate supported by Swift, while 17 percent say they are few More likely to vote for someone she supports. The one-point difference was within the margin of error, so don’t expect Georgia to go to Biden. I don’t want to tell the Illuminati how to do their job, but there are certainly better reasons to rig the Super Bowl. that.